28 pages • 56 minutes read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
“One Friday Morning” is a coming-of-age story—a high school senior begins the story with one set of assumptions and ends with a new awareness. At 17, Nancy Lee is still grappling with what it means to be a person of color in America. Overtly confronted with the reality of racism even in a Northern city, Hughes’s protagonist experiences a loss of innocence and must choose how to respond.
At the beginning, Nancy Lee is a precocious and gifted student, excelling in sports, in music, and in the classroom. “She was smart, pretty, and brown” (2), the listing suggests how Nancy Lee begins the story. The reality of her race does not occur to her to even matter. She fits into her white high school. Every now and then she reminds herself that she is “colored.” Yet she is proud of her African culture, raised by parents who introduced her to the “beauties of Africa, its strength, its songs, its mighty rivers…its ancient and important civilizations” (2). But she is proud as well of being an American, “a Negro American” (2).
Her art teacher encourages her to develop her talent. Nancy Lee is optimistic and idealistic, but she is vulnerable because she is naïve. Her world is beautiful, designed, like her paintings, “the lines sure, the colors bright and harmonious” (3).
The scholarship award initially confirms her optimism. She nearly dances all the way home. “Dreams began to dance in her head, plans and ambitions, beauties she would create for herself, her parents, and the Negro people” (5). When she is robbed of the scholarship because of her race, Nancy Lee understands in a shattering moment that the American Dream is not for her. Not now. Not yet. With Miss O’Shay’s guidance, however, she resists anger, despair, self-pity, or cynicism.
She regains her poise, gathers her dignity, and heads into her future determined to dedicate herself to making sure injustices like this do not happen again, not in America. That heroic resilience defines her transition into adulthood.
If the story tests the tensions between art and the real world, Miss Deitrich, Nancy Lee’s high school art teacher, emphasizes the power of the artist and of art itself.
Unlike the other art teachers in Nancy Lee’s school, Miss Dietrich, her art teacher and her mentor, believes that in her class students should strive not to imitate the works of classical painters but rather to discover through trial and error their original vision. Miss Dietrich “[brings] out the best in her students.” Under her encouragement, Nancy Lee blossoms into a promising artist because she sees a blank canvas as a chance to create something with a “meaning nobody else could give it” except Nancy Lee herself. Art, for Miss Dietrich, offers those committed to creativity and self-expression the chance to create worlds that were “clean, sharp, beautiful, individual” (2).
That credo is expressed in Nancy Lee’s scholarship-winning watercolor painting: a “charming” (3) unprepossessing landscape of a city park in the spring with white children playing in the sun, the new grass just greening, an American flag on a tall pole in the center, and just off to the side an “old Negro woman” (3) sitting happily on a bench. It is a world of harmony, order, balance, and diversity all centered on the ideal of America itself. The painting, Nancy Lee feels, came “out of her soul, her own life” (3).
Miss Dietrich’s celebration of artistic idealism—the joy of young and developing artists such as Nancy Lee in creating their own beautiful worlds of order and balance—gets shattered in the assistant-principal’s office the Friday morning when Miss O’Shay tells Nancy Lee she will not receive the scholarship. Art, as it turns out, is not enough. The artist’s elegant, created worlds cannot, in the end, trump the real-time world, messy, complicated, hurtful, and anything but logical.
Miss O’Shay, the elderly assistant-principal who first tells Nancy Lee she has won the prestigious scholarship and then three days breaks the news that she is not receiving the award, both acquiesces to the committee’s racist decision and assures Nancy Lee she will speak to the board of education over the summer.
Miss O’Shay also lifts Nancy Lee’s spirit by encouraging her that the project of American democracy is ongoing, highlighting the novel’s thematic interest in The Importance of Activism. Haloed by spring sunshine, her eyes full of “strength and courage,” Miss O’Shay counsels Nancy Lee that this setback should not deter her from realizing her dreams, that her talent is real and promising. She offers Nancy Lee the big picture that the young girl needs at that delicate moment: America demands work. She tells Nancy Lee how, not that long ago her people, the Irish, faced similar discrimination, similar frustrations. “We still have in this world of ours, democracy to make” (9). It is a difficult message of a cautious optimism tempered by realism.
Miss O’Shay’s encouragement helps keep Nancy Lee from giving into despair. The elderly woman’s voice becomes an “electric flow of strength to [her] hurt spirit” (9). The assistant-principal’s generous counsel opens Nancy Lee to the possibility of a new day, how being denied the chance at attend the city’s art academy is not the end of anything but rather the beginning of a young life now dedicated to the real work of building an America as great and as radiant as its ideals.
Plus, gain access to 9,250+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Langston Hughes